Are Beaches Open In Lauderdale By The Sea?, Break Even Case Interview Capital One, Seattle Youth Basketball Tournaments, Articles A

my wife and I pay our taxes and feel if that's not enough for our government, then "Too bad Charlie". No one I have talked to since I received this survey has known anything about it. Isn't this trespassing? 2017-2021 American Community Survey 5-year estimates are now available, including the Public Use Microdata Sample (PUMS) and Variance Replicate Estimate (VRE) Tables. I guess the fear that they may be prosecuted for trespassing on private property wasn't worth the questionnaire. I will also show it to any of my neighbors who might know my name and ask that they not answer any questions about us from anyone. Unreal! My husband said he is going to start asking them the personal questions and leave it at that. I'm a stay-at-home Momma with a toddler daughter. A: The ACS contains questions that go far beyond typical census questions about the number of individuals within the household and their age, race, and sex. Does this person have difficulty doing errands alone such as doctor's visits or shopping? If every household in the nation received this survey at once, there might be more of any outcry and uproar for our government to cut out the nonsense or face a revolution! [5] Unlike the decennial census which is sent out every 10 years, the ACS is an ongoing survey that is sent out on a continuous basis by the Census Bureau.[6]. Let this letter be the third request that you respect my privacy and my requests. I said I did not need any help. I ordered him to leave and he said he would have to go get the sheriff and return. I have written to the senators of my state and didn't even receive a 'canned' response. Just because some bureaucrat says that U.S. Code, Title 13 makes the American Community Survey legal and enforceable, the test of time will surely prove that it is not. I got no answer. I think that I will put this in the woodstove-just don't tell the EPA or they will be here to take away my woodstove. Where is the America I grew up in? We didn't send in the regular 2010 one and they came by the house. American Community Survey (ACS) - Census.gov Look it up. In support of this argument, the defendants submitted an assertion from ACS chief Donna Dailey, who assured that the Census Bureau does not threaten non-responding addresses with the enforcement of fines or with referral to [the Department of Justice] for prosecution. Dailey added that [i]n the history of the ACS, no one has ever been prosecuted for failing to respond to the survey, and that no one has ever been referred to the DOJ for prosecution, nor has the DOJ ever prosecuted someone, for failing to respond, the order shares. --JAS. Our town boasts 90,000 citizens, but we know there are at least an additional 10,000 illegals here (yes, here in Mexifornia). Explain that their responses will constitute consent to display the video online. I have one final question for anyone who thinks this is just an overreaction to a few census questions: If George Bush and Dick Cheney were sitting in the White House, and Halliburton was storing the data, would you still feel the same way? Q: Has the government prosecuted persons for refusing to answer the American Community Survey? I was in my PJs and answered the door, thinking it was a neighbor. (This is about 10:02 a.m. which is very early in my world since I work from noon till 9 p.m. Those of you who are interested just might try at least the internet to find out what this is all about. The Census Project works continuously to educate Congress about the critical importance of adequate yearly funding for 2020 Census planning and operations and for the American Community Survey. The second time I got a call, I followed the recommendation of a fellow patriot. Firm, clear refusal. I said that I still respectfully declined the survey. The founders feared the use of direct taxes so they created a system to discourage their use. I did call the police on them. He asked me about a census employee who visited my home the prior week. What kind of people do you have working for you? 1. I don't get mad about much but privacy is basic American. There are two of us living here. I received this census (which to clarify is not the 10 year one, we filled that one out). Unfortunately, the second time my husband gave in, as he felt we would get fined and was tired of the threats. They are a toothless tiger. Last year I was hounded by these people and they are back I am so glad I did not answer or call or contact them I cannot believe this information is relevant for city planningthe person above said it best. I gave them my name and not much more. So be it. I just got my request from ACS today, late july 2010. To all the census takers who have the nerve to put their 2 cents here to tell us how safe it is, why don't you also post your personal information for us? Filled out the short form months ago. While talking to the ACS lady on the phone I found out they didn't have a complete address and had sent me a form. If they aren't getting anything from my house and they've canvassed my six neighbors twice (actually talking to four of them). Just throw the census form in the trash. As a result, Congressional districts will need to be redrawn. I've read the Constitution now and I fail to find any foundation for anyone asking questions of this nature. However, I am sure I will get another one. We have been like a frog cooked in our own water slowly. I also, as many of you, returned my census form (as I should and as the Constitution requires) but this has gone so far over the line that it's ridiculous. I was really hoping she would stick around and argue with me some more, I was kind of of enjoying it because I knew there wasn't anything she could do. [20] https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/about/qbyqfact/2016/Language.pdf. This means that there is no class that can be joined or signed up for by any consumers who feel they may have been covered by the litigation. During the last survey I chose not to fill it out. If you are contacted by Census Bureau employees, either by telephone or in person, demanding your response, you can assert your rights by politely, but firmly, informing the employee that you believe the ACS is an improper invasion of your privacy, that you do not intend to respond and that they should not attempt to contact you again. Since then I have been visited a few times by a nice Dept. This also happened the last time. Why am I being asked what my age and birthdate are? I plead the 5th amendment because the government can ask legally, according to the attorneys office, but I can also remain silent legally. I've since received a second one, and had one call this week(which I did not answer). The provision for the Census is found in Article I, Section 2, Clause 3 of the Constitution. So I did not send it back. I've heard rumors that they will send their people to relentlessly pound on my door for answers, and then start canvassing the neighborhood to find the answers to the questions that were on my form, about me. The new research by the Trevor Project, which surveyed nearly 34,000 LGBTQ youth ages 13 to 24 across the United States in fall 2021, also found that Black and nonbinary young people reported . A few visits to my door that went unanswered, a few letters filled with empty threats, and after a month or so, and it all subsided. Quid pro quo," then slam the door in their face. I asked who he was and he attempted to open the screen door. That didn't stop the harassment, visits leaving notes while I was at work, or conversations asking my neighbors questions about me like I was some criminal or something. If it is kept under the radar, then there are not enough people screaming to make a difference. If we don't stand up and protect our rights we will lose them b/c the gvmt is all too happy to take as many away as possible for their own benefit at our expense. I would rather pay the $100 fine to keep my freedom in check. Someone brought up a good point, either here or on another forum. I may answer the door this time, but my attitude is going to be that I won't allow this to cause me any more stress than deciding what toppings I want on my pizza. A: The ACS is not sent to all households. These questions clearly violate any privacy guaranteed to me by the US Constitution and over step the Census Bureaus authority. Instead, you are encouraged to call one of the Census Bureau's two telephone centers directly to determine the legitimacy of the call you just received: Jeffersonville, IN: 1-800-523-3205. Although they have a mandate and articles and codes under the US code, this is all for the census not the ACS. Don't give in. I left the notice stuck to the door. Not to mention that this information in the wrong hands can cause identity theft. When neighbors gave them basic information, apparently the census taker then discussed the fact that they'd looked into tax records for "the residents of our home". I don't answer the door to anyone who comes. What time do the male members of your household go to work? This person has stopped to "chat" with the neighbors, asking who lives in our home, how many people, what their names are, what our schedules are. I told her the story and said I didn't have time for this right now. Q: Is this an unconstitutional invasion of privacy? The present state of affairs is a direct result of our collective ignorance. The government is doing nothing wrong! So I received two ACS forms in the mail and they are not going to be filled out. It is so obvious that the same person keeps responding over and over here. we need to stop fighting and come together, reminiscent of the black panthers and Raymond Washington. I guarantee it will be a short and polite conversation and the last time they ever bother you! Census worker says "I am with the census.". Three times they sent people to our door, and three times I walked out the back door, and turned on the water. They have to get past the doorman first. BTW my survey went into the guinea pig cage, it will come out the same it went in: crap. With the census bureau losing over 600 laptops, and the current abuses of power, I see no reason to give out the information that they are asking. this person got in the building somehow! Outrageous! The House GOP proposal would eliminate any increase in funds for 2020 planning, and it cuts nearly $500 million in total from the administration's request, including reductions for the American. There should be a law against this. Have no fear. Before commenting, please review our comment policy. I've been harassed by phone at night and Sundays. Anything more is intrusive. We just got the letter today, to expect the questionnaire. [4] After a decennial census is conducted, states which have increases in population may gain additional seats in the House of Representatives at the expense of other states. A sympathizer to the Census said it was to help the government to function. For over a quarter century, we have assisted, without charge, persons deprived of their liberty by government officials. Further, congressional rules on enforcement were controlled by the Republican Congressional Committee overseeing Census Bureau Operations, when the Republicans controlled congress. ), so did my 80 year old mother in another state. In 1990 I returned the long form and after a couple weeks one of their incompetents showed at my doorstep saying I hadn't returned it. Follow your happiness and I promise the universe will be there for you: subtle, slow, obvious or quick it will respond to your emotions. Fiscal Year 2024 Letter to OMB Director Shalanda Young encouraging the Administration to prioritize funding for the U.S. Census Bureau and 2030 Census in its FY 2024 You'd better hope that you are aren't one of the unlucky three. On 22 September 2006, the American Broadcast Company (ABC) reported that, since 2003, the Census Bureau lost or reported stolen over 200 laptops and numerous handheld and portable data devices used by survey collectors. Low-Income Renters Spent Larger Share of Income on Rent in 2021 Just got my second second ACS survey in the last three years. She stated that her supervisor sent her back out. He came to my door anyway. The Founding Fathers wanted the power to stay with the people - but it took a revolution to secure it. Since when has the Federal government come to my door or anyone elses and said "We want to help you get your road paved" or any other helpful act, and then asked me for my help by filling out a form to prove the necessity? I started researching and am grateful for the advice by others here and on other sites. They can have my age, race, sex and opinion about corruption in government. If you had a wife who had been sexually assaulted, would you want the time you left for and came home from work circulated? 10 minutes ago I felt apprehensive. I since looked through the forms for the ACS on their site and it does ask far to much personal info. I grabbed the handle and slammed the door shut. Their bosses are going like it even less. 4) If they do not agree to answer any personal questions, assume the Hannibal Lecter voice and say "Tut, tut, tut. IE: IRS, DOT, Labor and Industry. It sure the hell is. Rights Radio with Dr. Joyce Starr I would feel dirty if I accepted a job with the census. The American Community Survey (ACS) qualifies as a government program whose purpose, while seemingly benign, raises significant constitutional concerns. PDF Methodology I decided I did not want to answer the census because of the invasiveness of the questions. The BIG 2010 census count is coming soon. Your name, address and phone number (front cover of the ACS), 2. This is how those rich people are rich, those "powerful" people are "powerful", and those happy people are happy. It seems what is good for the goose is not good for the gander. US Census, American Community Survey data collection: Beneficial, or Thank you, fellow Americans! When hell freezes over. Maybe they should change the name of the survey to "American Communist Survey". I noticed a car pull up to my neighbor's house. One of the three enumerators did canvass my neighbors and got hold of one of them, who tried to call me and advised the census people were looking for me (I did not return the voicemail). They are not! Washington and California residents have filed a proposed class action in which they object to being asked to participate in theAmerican Community Survey, which enquires about certain demographic details more specific than those central to the decennial Census. I firmly told her I had no intention of filling out the survey as I felt it was no one's business. In 2000 I refused to fill mine out. As a descendant of both victims and survivors of the Auschwitz death camps, I have a keen sense of the length and breadth of what government intrusion in the lives of private citizens can result in. I do believe that the census information is mostly kept private though after a period of years or decades, it may become public. How Banks Can Serve Customers with Language Barriers I responded to the ACS. We are entitled to "Quiet Enjoyment" of our homes. Millions of dollars wasted! I was mailed two ACS forms which I promptly threw in the trash because of the personal nature of the questions. They came to my door at all hours. I work for a defense contractor, and when I applied for a security clearance, there were way fewer questions, and much less invasive than were on the ACS long form. After spending almost an hour answering questions the first time the census take came to my house, they start calling me on Sunday afternoon -- enough is enough! I guess it's too simple, or full of common sense. I can understand the desire to keep the information private. Cowards! Different people call at all hours and they block the name and number. The questionnaire also demands that you give other information on the people in your home, such as their educational levels, how many years of school were completed, what languages they speak and when they last worked at a job, among other things. I told the second person who called me that I had already refused to cooperate with the first person who called. I'm paid 400 goats and a chest of elderberries in barter for my services. Official websites use .gov It has been done since 1790, and is mandated by the Constitution. I included a note with the returned survey stating that I would continue to refuse to answer these additional questions as a matter of principle, and I requested that no phone calls or visits to my home be made by your agency. One concern with the collection of such private information, especially financial information, is that ACS information could be compared to information provided to the Internal Revenue Service on tax returns. Not about us - about adjoining property! The next day, a woman came to my gate and was asking me to fill out the form with her. I told them I was not responding, and as I shut the door and walked away she stood on the porch and rang the bell, and since then it's all gone down hill. In July, I started to receive visits. [14] https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/about/qbyqfact/2016/StructureRooms.pdf. Subscribe to GovDelivery email updates to stay up-to-date on the latest news and events about the American Community Survey. The US Census Bureau makes it clear that the American Community Survey (ACS) is authorized under Sections 141 and 193 of Title 13 of the United States Code, and that compliance with the survey is legally mandatory. Why would anyone want to "help the government function" (interfere in our private lives)? When approached by census officials I will state that my religious beliefs prohibit giving any information beyond my name and the number of people in my house. Here's what it says online: The American Community Survey is a legitimate survey conducted by the CensusBureau. Or maybe they're going to start sending happy birthday cards to everybody soon. With identity theft on the rise, many are concerned. Finally, she said I am not answering anymore questions and they left her alone. I was just contacted by a representative for the Census Bureau at my home and asked to answer his questions. I also feel for the ones who fought and died for us, who spit in their graves. The ACS and Census Bureau have no legal standing to enforce the bogus laws that were passed to allow this survey. I am appalled by the questions asked on the ACS! Ha! Thank Gosh, I documented every call and person I spoke with. The states collect the tax and turn the money over to the federal government. Are we going to let this happen? I'll see "YOU" on the tube."You Tube". A week later, the same worker showed up and said it was my last chance or I could be fined and possibly jailed. Suggestions include "With whom did you last have a sexual encounter and when and where did this take place? We haven't been bothered since. We do not have to fear picking up the phone or answering our door. He asked if I would consent to a phone survey and I could decline from answering any questions I thought were too personal or intrusive. He was shocked and said it was required by law. I'm planning on returning it blank, with a letter stating the reason for not complying is the OMB# expiration. These "enumerators" aren't policemen and they can't make you answer their questions or let them into your house. I have therefore included both Article 1 section 2 of the US Constitution, and the US Supreme courts decisions in upholding the right to privacy. I made the mistake of answering some questions, thinking it was a one time thing. They are instilling fear. I have a right to not be harassed in my home.